Back to the Tobacco Law Center home page

Tracking Tobacco Laws

Tracking Tobacco Laws: A Minnesota Digest

A plain-language resource for local officials, attorneys, public health professionals and advocates is now hyperlinked to all state and federal laws, regulations and legal settlements that affect the sale, marketing and use of tobacco in Minnesota.

Sample Ordinances

Prohibiting Individual or Out-of-Package Sale of Cigarettes PDF, 101 Kb

Eliminating Smoking in Public Places and Places of Work PDF, 49 Kb

Eliminating Smoking in Restaurants PDF, 48 Kb

Eliminating Smoking in Public Places and Places of Work, Exempting Bars PDF, 52 Kb

Editorial

Putting truth into action: using the evidence for justice

PDF, 126 Kb
D Douglas Blanke, Hubert H Humphrey III
Tobacco Control 2006;15(Suppl IV):iv1–iv3.

Legislation and Litigation

Minnesota's Tobacco Settlement

Minnesota's 1998 settlement with major cigarette manufacturers remains a milestone in American legal history. The world's fourth largest legal settlement, it not only generates hundreds of millions of dollars annually — forever — for Minnesota's treasury, but also imposes permanent legal restrictions on the activities of the cigarette manufacturers. Among other things, the settlement:

  • Prohibits marketing to youth.
  • Prohibits misrepresentations about the health consequences of tobacco use.
  • Bans merchandise bearing cigarette brand names or logos.
  • Ends cigarette billboards and transit advertising.
  • Bans any payment for the placement of cigarettes in movies.
  • Prohibits anti-competitive practices.
  • Requires disclosure of the companies' lobbying expenditures.
  • Requires cigarette manufacturers to maintain public document depositories to house 30 million pages of once-secret documents disclosed in the case.
  • Sets aside $200 million to help smokers who want to quit, support tobacco-related research and promote tobacco control.

The settlement is contained in these two interrelated legal documents.

Master Settlement Agreement

The Master Settlement Agreement (MSA) is an accord reached in November 1998 between the state Attorneys General of forty-six states, five U.S. territories, the District of Columbia and the five largest tobacco companies in America concerning the advertising, marketing and promotion of tobacco products. In addition to requiring the tobacco industry to pay the settling states approximately $10 billion annually for the indefinite future, the MSA also set standards for, and imposed restrictions on, the sale and marketing of cigarettes by participating cigarette manufacturers.

Among its many provisions, the MSA:

  • Forbids participating cigarette manufacturers from directly or indirectly targeting youth;
  • Imposes significant prohibitions or restrictions on advertising, marketing and promotional programs or activities; and
  • Bans or restricts cartoons, transit advertising, most forms of outdoor advertising, including billboards, product placement in media, branded merchandise, free product samples (except in adult-only facilities), and most sponsorships

Download the MSA PDF, 270 Kb

Tobacco Control Legislation, Second Edition An Introductory Guide (WHO, 2004)

PDF, 1.77 Mb

Edited by the Tobacco Law Center's Director, this World Health Organization handbook offers health officials and others the tools to develop the legislation required by the historic Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, the first global health treaty. The first in a series of WHO capacity-building manuals, it is intended to help make the FCTC a turning point in the struggle to reverse the global epidemic of tobacco use. The Guide explains the stages of the legislative process, from building a foundation of political support, to enforcement and evaluation of laws after their enactment. It describes strategic choices countries must make in approaching legislation, and offers practical suggestions for drafting, lobbying, and overcoming obstacles. Included are an examination of the key elements of comprehensive legislation; a discussion of international law and its relation to tobacco control; and nine country studies illustrating successful strategies used around the world. Click on the link to download the PDF file of this book.

Studies and Reports

Minding the Store: Curtailing the Sale of Tobacco to Minnesota Teens

PDF, 1.9 Mb

Prepared for the Minnesota Department of Health, this report provides an overview of the Minnesota laws that govern the sale of tobacco products to minors and details existing enforcement practices. Based on a local retail enforcement survey and profiles of enforcement practices in eight other states, the report identifies key barriers to effective local enforcement and recommends statewide improvements.

Smoke on the Web: Can Children Buy Cigarettes Online?

PDF, 655 Kb

This report, prepared for the Minnesota Department of Health, examines the practical and conceptual problems that arise when tobacco products are sold via the internet. Based on an investigation of nearly a hundred websites and an experiment of underage youth acting as buyers, the report identifies problems in current enforcement, outlines possibilities for future enforcement, and recommends state-level improvements.

Towards Health with Justice: Litigation and Public Inquiries as Tools for Tobacco Control

PDF, 604 Kb

Prepared for the Tobacco Free Initiative of the World Health Organization, the report outlines the history of tobacco litigation in the United States and the development of global tobacco litigation. It also analyzes the risks and benefits of tobacco litigation, explores other options, and recommends international steps to move forward.

Tobacco Company Strategies to Undermine Tobacco Control Activities at the World Health Organization, Report of the Committee of Experts on Tobacco Industry Documents

(WHO, 2000) PDF, 1591 Kb

Prepared by a global Committee of Experts appointed by the Director General of the World Health Organization, this landmark report examines internal tobacco industry documents to uncover elaborate, sophisticated and long-running efforts by tobacco manufacturers to sabotage the tobacco control initiatives of the WHO. The Director of the Tobacco Law Center served as a research consultant to the Committee of Experts in investigating the industry's activities and drafting this report.

Other Publications

» To obtain a full copy of an article not available for download here, contact tobaccolaw@wmitchell.edu.

Clean indoor air: Where, why, and how.

Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics, 30(3) Suppl:75-82, 2002.

Henson R, Medina L, St. Clair S, Blanke D, Downs L.

This article focuses on clean indoor air policies as a way to eliminate exposure to secondhand smoke, especially on laws at the state level, ordinances at the local level, and preemptive clauses that limit the power of local governments to impose their own smoking restrictions above and beyond those of state law. Developments and experiences in Minnesota and Iowa are discussed in more detail.

Science for hire: A tobacco industry strategy to influence public opinion on secondhand smoke.

Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 5(3):303-314, 2003.

Muggli ME, Hurt RD, Blanke DD.

A review of internal tobacco company documents reveals that members of the tobacco industry and its corporate attorneys created an international scientific consultants program to influence public opinion on environmental tobacco smoke (ETS). This program was shaped as a “product” to protect the industry from international threats of smoking restrictions. Additionally, this program was used to promote a scientific backdrop supporting the industry's position on ETS that differed from regulatory agencies and published scientific research. In this report, we detail the pervasive nature of the so-called ETS Consultants Program, outline the wide range of activities undertaken by the consultants, and highlight the role of the industry's corporate attorneys in creating and managing this program. We suggest heightened monitoring of industry-created scientific organizations, further tobacco document research, and wide dissemination of such work.

Should your state have a public health law center?

Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics, 31(4)Special Suppl:58-59, 2003.

Moore J, Ashe M, Gray P, Blanke D.

Legal Resources for Tobacco Control

PDF, 752 Kb

This resource guide, compiled by a national network of legal resource centers and tobacco law experts, provides legal tools primarily for public policy initiatives. Lists of resources include a brief description of the resource and its intended audience. Separate lists are provided by state and organization and by subject area.

PowerPoint Presentations

Presentations viewable only with Internet Explorer

Freedom To Breathe A summary of the “Freedom to Breathe” Act, the substantive changes to the Minnesota Clean Indoor Air Act, passed by the Minnesota legislature in May 2007, 210 Kb

The Framework Convention: Globalizing Tobacco Control. Reducing Tobacco Use: Research into Action, February 28, 2005

Regulation of Tobacco Products: Where We Stand. Reducing Tobacco Use: Research into Action, February 28, 2005

Smoke-Free Policies: Some Legal Perils and Pitfalls, Best of the West Conference, July 23, 2004, 1.8 Mb

Report from the Courts, Best of the West Conference, July 23, 2004, 1.4 Mb

Avoiding Legal Pitfalls in Smoke-Free Ordinance Campaigns, Community Health Conference, September, 2004

Lobbying by Government Employees: Do’s and Don’ts, 521 Kb

Clean Indoor Air and Preemption: The Minnesota Experience, 558 Kb

Tobacco Control Legislation: An Overview March 2004, 2664 Kb

Legal Update: A Report from the Courts Jan. 29, 2004, 2558 Kb

“Get a Lawyer!”: Legal Support for Smoke-free Policy Campaigns Jan. 29, 2004, 760 Kb

Controlling Internet Tobacco Sales: Legal and Practical Challenges Dec. 12, 2003, 917 Kb

Legal Responses to the Tobacco Epidemic: Litigation as a Global Tool August 2003, 1342 Kb